The tenant you approve in a hurry is the one you end up thinking about for a year. I screen every applicant the same way, in the same order, with the same paperwork, whether the unit is a studio or a three-bedroom. That sameness is the whole point. Screening is not about finding perfect tenants. It is about having a process you can defend, and a file that proves you followed it.
Start with the money, because New York already capped it for you. There is no application fee in this state. The only thing you can charge is the actual cost of a background and credit check, and that is capped at $20, whichever is less. If the applicant hands you a background or credit check done in the past 30 days, you waive the fee entirely. And when you do charge for your own check, you have to give the applicant a copy of the report and the receipt from the company that ran it. That is Real Property Law 238-a, and it has been the rule since the 2019 housing law. A broker or manager who charges a $75 application fee is not being thorough. They are breaking the law, and the paper trail points at you.
The second rule is about what you are allowed to judge. In New York City, you cannot refuse an applicant because of where their income comes from. That has been the law since 2008, under the city's Human Rights Law, and it covers Section 8 vouchers, CityFHEPS, SSI, child support, and every other lawful source. A voucher holder only has to show they can pay their share of the rent, not the full rent. You can still say no for a legitimate reason — the total income does not work, the rental history does not check out, the references do not answer. But you cannot apply a stricter standard to a voucher holder than to anyone else, and you cannot advertise a unit as no programs. The Commission on Human Rights can fine up to $250,000 per violation, and it actively tests landlords with paired applicants. The old 40-times-rent rule of thumb is still a useful yardstick for total income. It is not a license to screen out a voucher.
The third rule is about timing. Under the city's Fair Chance for Housing Act, which took effect January 1, 2025, you cannot run a criminal background check until after you have made a conditional offer. The check comes last, not first. And do not reject someone just because they once appeared in housing court. A prior case is not a verdict on the tenant, and treating it as one is exactly the kind of shortcut that gets a file questioned.
So what does a good screening file actually contain? The application, the report, the receipt, the income verification, the prior-landlord reference, and one line noting the reason for the decision — approved or declined. Same checklist, same order, every time. When the decision is ever questioned, by the applicant, by a regulator, or by your own partner a year later, the file is the answer. If it is not written down, it did not happen.
Most landlords treat screening as paperwork. I treat it as the cheapest insurance on the building. A lease is a year or two long. A bad screening decision is a year or two of collections calls, court dates, and a unit you cannot turn. Twenty dollars and a complete file will not find you a perfect tenant. But it will keep you from approving the wrong one in a hurry, and it will keep the decision you made standing up when somebody asks you to explain it.
← All insights