On the first of the month, we already know who is going to be late. Not because we have a crystal ball. Because we keep a ledger, and the same ten apartments show up in it every month like clockwork.
Here is the part most new landlords get wrong: they treat collections as something that starts when rent is late. In our buildings, collections starts on the 1st. An automated reminder goes out that morning. On the 2nd, we review the ledger — who paid, who is partial, who is silent. By the 3rd, we have a list.
The calendar matters because the law sets it for us. In New York, you cannot charge a late fee until rent is more than five days past due, and the fee is capped at the lesser of $50 or 5% of the monthly rent. That is Real Property Law 238-a, from the 2019 housing reforms. So the 5th is a legal line, and our process is built around it, not behind it.
On the 6th, we call. Not a letter, a call. Most late rent is administrative — a lost check, a portal hiccup, a payday that lands on the 3rd. A two-minute phone call clears those in a way a formal letter never does. The tenants who intend to pay are relieved to hear from us. The ones who don't will tell you exactly that, and now you know.
The late fee is a nudge, not revenue. Fifty dollars on a $2,000 apartment does not move the needle on a building's income statement. Its only job is to make paying on the 1st slightly more attractive than paying on the 9th. Any landlord budgeting late fees as income is managing a building that is already behind.
When the call doesn't work, the escalation is mechanical: a written payment plan with short timelines. Two weeks, not six months. Everything in writing, signed, with a clear date. If the plan is missed, the legal clock resumes exactly where it left off — you never reset the timeline, you never start over because you felt bad.
What never happens: skipping steps. No threats that don't match the lease, no personal visits that feel like intimidation, no mixing the late fee into the rent demand. Every step is documented, every notice goes out on the schedule the lease and the law require. Boring, predictable, airtight.
The buildings with the best collections numbers don't have the toughest landlords. They have the earliest calendar. Rent is due on the 1st, and the operator who acts like it on the 1st rarely has to act tough on the 15th.
← All insights