Every building I look at has two rent rolls. The first is the one tenants actually pay. The second is the one the market would pay. The gap between them has a name, and it is the most useful number most owners never calculate: loss to lease.

Loss to lease is simple arithmetic. For each occupied unit, subtract the rent the tenant pays today from the rent that same unit would command on the open market today. Add those gaps up across the building. That total, in dollars per month, is your loss to lease. If a tenant pays $1,800 for a unit that would rent for $2,000, that unit carries $200 a month of loss to lease. Nothing is actually lost in the sense of cash out the door. It is rent you could be earning but are not, yet.

The first thing this number does is stop you from fooling yourself about a rent roll. A building can look fully occupied and still be under-earning by thousands of dollars a month, because the leases were signed years ago and the market moved on. Occupancy tells you whether units are filled. Loss to lease tells you whether they are filled at the right price. You need both, and they answer different questions.

The second thing it does is set your renewal plan. When I see a building with a big loss to lease, I do not see a reason to raise every rent at once. I see a schedule. Units with the largest gaps and the nearest expirations get attention first. Units with small gaps can wait. A phased plan lets you capture rent over several renewal cycles instead of handing tenants one big increase and watching half of them leave at the same time.

That trade-off is the whole discipline of the metric. A large loss to lease is upside, but it is also turnover risk. Push too hard and you trade a below-market tenant for a vacant unit, a turn cost, and months of downtime, which usually costs more than the increase was worth. The right question is never just how big the gap is. It is how much of the gap you can close without losing the tenant, and what it costs you when you cannot.

Loss to lease can also run the other way, and that matters just as much. When a tenant pays more than market, the building carries a gain to lease, which is really a warning label. That rent is at risk the day the lease expires or the tenant walks, because the market will not replace it at the same number. I would rather underwrite a building honestly at market than pretend an above-market lease will renew forever.

So I run this number unit by unit, every time, before I talk about rent growth at all. It takes a rent roll, a set of honest market comps, and a calculator. No new software, no consultant. What it gives you is the difference between hoping rents will grow and knowing exactly where the growth is hiding, how big it is, and what order to go after it in.

← All insights