I used to watch good applicants walk away at the last step, not over the rent, but over the broker fee. A tenant would tour the apartment, like the apartment, agree to the rent, and then learn they owed a fee to a broker they never hired, often around a month's rent or 12 to 15 percent of a year's rent. That was the deal-breaker, and it was built into how New York City leasing worked for decades.
That changed on June 11, 2025, when New York City's Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses Act, known as the FARE Act (Local Law 119 of 2024), took effect. The rule is simple: whoever hires the broker pays the broker. If I hire a broker to list and rent my apartment, I pay that broker. A broker who works for the landlord, or who publishes a listing with the landlord's permission, cannot charge the tenant a fee for that rental.
The one exception proves the rule. If a tenant hires their own broker to search on their behalf, that tenant pays their own broker, under whatever agreement they signed. Nobody can make renting an apartment depend on the tenant hiring or paying a broker. So the question to ask on every listing is no longer how much the fee is. It is who hired the broker, and that answer decides who pays.
For an owner, this did not make the fee disappear. It moved it onto my side of the ledger, where it belongs as a leasing cost. A broker fee that used to land on the tenant at move-in is now a cost I have to underwrite alongside the turn, the painting, and the vacancy days between tenants. That changes the math on a vacancy in a useful way: a fast, well-priced lease with a fee attached can still beat a long vacancy with no fee at all, but only if I priced the fee into the deal before I listed, not after I found a tenant.
The law also changed the paperwork, and this is where sloppy operators get caught. Any fee the tenant must pay has to be disclosed in the listing and in the lease, before the tenant signs, with an itemized list the tenant signs. Renaming a broker fee as a key fee or an administrative fee does not get around it. The city's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection enforces the law, with penalties of up to $2,000 per violation. If a fee is not disclosed, it should not be collected.
Here is how I run it now. First, I decide before listing whether I am hiring a broker at all, and if so, I agree the fee in writing and put it in the leasing budget for that unit. Second, I track cost per signed lease the same way I track cost per turn: fee plus vacancy days plus turn cost, divided by the lease term. Third, I compare that number to a renewal, which usually wins, because a renewal has no broker fee and no vacancy. The FARE Act did not make leasing free. It made the true cost visible, and visible costs are the ones you can manage.
The practical lesson is the same one that runs through every line of a building's budget: a cost you push onto someone else does not go away, it just shows up somewhere worse, like a longer vacancy or a lost applicant. Since June 2025, the broker fee shows up where it always belonged, on the landlord's side. Budget for it, disclose what the tenant actually owes, and price the lease with the whole cost in view. That is how you fill apartments without losing good tenants at the finish line.
← All insights