Every building has a line below which you are writing checks out of your own pocket. Most owners never calculate where that line is. They know their occupancy, they know their rent roll, and they assume the gap between the two is comfortable. Break-even occupancy removes the assumption. It tells you, in one number, how empty the building can get before it stops supporting itself.
The math is simple. Add up your annual operating expenses — taxes, insurance, utilities, maintenance, management, reserves — then add your annual debt service, the full year's mortgage payments. Divide that total by your gross potential income, the rent the building would produce if every unit were leased all year. The result is your break-even occupancy. If the number comes out at 80 percent, the building covers every bill at 80 percent occupancy. The other 20 percent is your cushion.
Take a 24-unit building with $360,000 a year in potential rent. Operating expenses run $144,000. Annual debt service is another $144,000. Add them together — $288,000 — and divide by $360,000. The break-even occupancy is 80 percent. That building can lose roughly five units to vacancy, concessions, or nonpayment before it stops covering its own costs. Change one input and watch what happens: put less money down, and the bigger loan pushes debt service up and the break-even with it. Raise the insurance premium by $12,000, and the cushion shrinks by more than three points.
There are rough bands for judging the result. Below 80 percent is strong — the building can absorb a real vacancy spike and keep paying its bills. Between 80 and 85 percent is workable, and it is roughly where most lenders want to see you: a break-even below 85 percent is the usual threshold in commercial underwriting. Above 85 percent the margin gets thin. Above 90 percent you are one bad stretch away from subsidizing the building yourself, because a single eviction, a major repair, or a slow leasing season can push you under the line.
I run this number alongside DSCR, because the two answer different questions. DSCR tells you how much income covers the mortgage at today's occupancy. Break-even occupancy tells you how far occupancy can fall before the income stops covering anything. A 1.25 DSCR at full occupancy roughly corresponds to an 80 percent break-even — decent coverage, decent cushion. But a building can show a fine DSCR at 95 percent occupancy and still have a 92 percent break-even, which means it has almost no room for a bad month. The DSCR looks healthy. The break-even exposes the fragility.
It also pairs with economic occupancy, which I wrote about yesterday. Economic occupancy measures what you actually collect after vacancy, concessions, and bad debt. Break-even occupancy measures what you need to collect. Put them side by side and you get the honest picture: your economic occupancy is where you are, your break-even is the floor, and the distance between them is how much trouble you can afford.
If the number comes out too high, there are only three levers. Cut operating expenses — renegotiate the insurance, bill utilities back to tenants, fix the leak that keeps generating work orders. Reduce debt service — more equity at purchase, or a cheaper rate. Or raise gross potential income — higher rents, laundry and parking income, fees you are actually entitled to charge. The lever to watch is the third one, because it is the easiest to fake. If you run the math on pro forma rents instead of in-place rents, the denominator grows and the break-even looks better than it is. Run it on the rent you actually collect today, then run it again on stabilized rent, and believe the first number.
The real test is not the average vacancy in your market. It is the worst vacancy your market has seen. If the local vacancy rate hit 10 percent in the last downturn and your break-even is 90 percent, you have no margin at all — the last bad market would have put you underwater. A building either supports itself or you support it. Break-even occupancy tells you which one it is, before you buy it.
← All insights