Here is a mistake I see in a lot of new-construction underwriting: the tax line is treated like a plug number. Someone assumes the old 421-a benefit, or assumes full taxes forever, and moves on. In New York City, neither assumption works anymore, because the program changed. If you are looking at a new rental building, the first tax question is not what the taxes are today. It is which program the building is in, and what that program requires.
The old program, 421-a, stopped accepting new starts on June 15, 2022. For almost two years after that, the city had no standing tax exemption for new rental construction. That gap ended on April 20, 2024, when the state adopted its replacement: Real Property Tax Law Section 485-x, formally called the Affordable Neighborhoods for New Yorkers program. It is an exemption, not a simple discount. In plain terms, the owner keeps paying tax on the land and the building as assessed before construction starts, and the exemption covers the value the new construction adds.
485-x applies to new rental buildings in New York City with six or more units. That six-unit floor matters. A small building below that line does not get into the program at all, so its tax line has to be underwritten at full freight. Hotels are excluded. For the buildings that do qualify, the deal is straightforward in structure, even if the paperwork is not: build new rental housing, set aside a share of the apartments at restricted rents, and receive a long tax exemption in return.
The affordable share depends on size. Smaller rental projects, generally 6 to 99 units, set aside 20 percent of their units as affordable. Larger projects, 100 units and up, set aside 25 percent. The affordability levels are tied to area median income, with a weighted average of no more than 60 percent or 80 percent of area median income depending on the project size, and no single income band above 100 percent. Under 485-x, that affordability is permanent. It does not sunset the way some older benefits did, which means the restricted units stay restricted for the life of the building.
The length of the benefit also depends on size and location, running roughly 25 to 40 years. The largest rental projects in the designated zones can receive up to 40 years, including a full exemption period followed by a phase-out. Mid-sized and smaller projects receive shorter terms. That spread is exactly why you cannot copy a tax assumption from one deal to another. Two buildings on similar blocks can have very different tax lines for the next three decades simply because one has 90 units and the other has 110.
Larger projects also carry extra requirements, including construction wage rules and a requirement to use women- and minority-owned businesses for a share of design and construction costs. Most projects must file for the exemption within six months of starting construction. Miss that window and there is generally no way to opt in later in construction. I treat that deadline the same way I treat a loan deadline: it goes on the calendar on day one, with an owner, not in a file to be found later.
So when I underwrite a new rental deal now, I work through the tax line in order. First, does the project qualify for 485-x, and did it start construction in the eligible window, after June 15, 2022 and before June 15, 2034, with completion by June 15, 2038? Second, what is the required affordable share and income level, and is that baked into the rent roll, not added as an afterthought? Third, how long does the exemption run, and what happens to taxes when it phases out? A building that only works while the exemption is at full strength is a building with a refinancing problem already built into it. Get those three answers right, and the tax line stops being a guess. It becomes what it should be: a schedule you can underwrite, year by year, for as long as you plan to own the building.
← All insights