The elevator is the only piece of equipment in the building that every tenant uses every single day, and nobody thinks about it until the day it stops between floors with a stroller inside. Then it becomes the whole job: the phone calls, the entrapment, the repair bill, and the question everyone asks next — what kind of contract did we sign?

There are really only two kinds. An oil-and-grease contract runs roughly $1,800 to $4,500 a year per elevator: lubrication, minor adjustments, and callback labor for small issues. A full-maintenance contract runs roughly $4,500 to $12,000 a year per elevator and covers parts and labor for most repairs. Those are 2026 ranges, and the spread is the whole decision. On an oil-and-grease contract, every real repair is your bill. On a full-maintenance contract, deferred maintenance costs the elevator company, not you — which changes whose problem a worn door operator is.

The trap is the exclusions list, and every full-maintenance contract has one. The phrase “full maintenance” means full maintenance of the items included in the contract, not full coverage of the machine. Standard exclusions are vandalism, cab modernization, code-mandated upgrades, and obsolete parts — and “obsolete” is defined however the contractor wants to define it. After-hours labor is usually billed separately too, at roughly $150 to $300 an hour, and the annual safety tests can run $500 to $1,500 when they are billed apart from the contract. That is the second price. The monthly number is the teaser; the exclusions are the bill.

Then there is the compliance calendar, which the contract does not run for you. In New York City every elevator needs an annual Category 1 safety test, a Category 5 full-load test every five years, and a separate visual periodic inspection once each calendar year, at least three months apart from that year’s Category 1. The tests have to be performed by one DOB-approved agency and witnessed by a second, independent DOB-approved agency. Category test reports get filed with the DOB within 21 days; periodic inspection reports within 14. Miss a deadline and you are looking at violations, and a missed Category 5 can put the car out of service. Your maintenance company does the work. The filing deadline is still your problem.

So before I sign or renew one of these, I read the exclusions before I read the price, and I ask three questions. First, what exactly counts as obsolete on this machine, and who decides? Second, what is the after-hours rate, and does the contract include any nights and weekends at all? Third, who files the DOB reports, and who calls me if a filing is late? If the answers are vague, the contract is vague, and vague contracts are the ones that produce a $9,000 invoice in the same month the elevator is already down.

Which contract is right depends on the machine. A newer low-rise hydraulic in a quiet building can be the cheaper bet on oil-and-grease, with a real reserve set aside for the repairs you know are coming. An old traction car in a busy building with 40 units is a full-maintenance machine, because the repair frequency will eat the savings on the cheap contract inside a year. The mistake is picking by the monthly number alone. Price the contract the way you would price the elevator: by what breaks, who pays, and when.

An elevator is a small line in the operating budget until the day it is not. Read the exclusions, calendar the three DOB deadlines, and pick the contract that matches the age of the machine — not the one with the smallest monthly number. The tenants will never thank you for a working elevator. They will absolutely notice the week it does not work.

← All insights